The $50 Per-Lead Mistake That Cost My Client Thousands.

Can I tell you about a mistake I made that cost my client tens of thousands in potential business in just one month?

I’ve worked with this client for many years, and Google Ads has been very effective for their business. We started with fewer than 100 leads a month. Over the next five years, we scaled it up to about 4,000 a month while maintaining profitability.

The client asked me to meet with the head of his new department. In a bold move, he’d hired an entire team from a competitor. Now, he needed me to fill their pipeline with potential clients.

The client introduced us and then dashed off to another meeting.

The head of the department briefed me. Her department charged $495 for their service. They had a strong closing rate, so at $50 per lead, they’d be able to hit their profit target (and she’d secure her bonus).

We came up with a strategy together, and I went off to build the Google Ads and landing pages. A few days later, the first leads started coming in. Within a month, we’d settled into a steady but modest lead flow, just a smidge under our target of $50 per lead.

The problem was that although we hit the cost-per-lead target, we weren't getting enough leads to keep the team busy. Our $50-per-lead cap limited our competitiveness against businesses willing to pay more.

About a month after we started, I met with the client again. He was concerned because he’d hoped for many more leads. He was on the hook for salaries for the new department, but they’d only closed a handful of deals.

When I explained that we hadn’t received more leads because of the $50-per-lead cap, he got grumpy with the head of the department.

She’d significantly underestimated the value of a lead. Her department made $495 per client, but every client who needed their service also required a range of downstream services. A client who signed up for the $495 service inevitably signed up for the rest.

In the first year, a new client was worth about $11,000. Over the next 15 years, they’d be worth at least $750 each year. We could spend $200 per lead and still be profitable.

I adjusted our target cost per lead, and the lead volume picked up. After a few months of testing, we found that $90 per lead gave us enough volume to keep the team working at capacity.

It might seem unfair that I blame myself for the missed opportunities in the first month. After all, the head of the department gave me the wrong information. But, I was wrong to assume she understood the concept of customer lifetime value. Truth is, she’d probably never heard the phrase before and might have been too embarrassed to admit it.

Every successful Google Ads implementation has five key facets:

1. The person managing your ads must understand both Google Ads and your business.
2. A high-converting website or landing page.
3. A process for turning leads into sales.
4. A feedback loop to improve lead quality.
5. Clear profit tracking from campaigns.

I dropped the ball on the first. I misunderstood a key part of the business. It was my fault.

I’ve since updated my client onboarding checklist to make sure this doesn't happen again. I now ask far more detailed questions about how the business makes money. Onboarding takes longer, but we're more likely to succeed.

If you own a business, how confident are you that the person running your ads day-to-day truly understands your business? If you haven’t had a conversation where they ask deep, probing questions, there’s a good chance you’re not getting the most out of your ad spend. It might be worthwhile to ask, “How do we make money?” Not as a trap if they don’t know, but as a way to start helping them understand your business better.

Related articles

Why a Google Ads account audit Isn't enough

Testing Google Ads for an RV Campground

Why negative keywords are becoming less effective in Google Ads

What’s the right bidding strategy for a brand new Google Ads account?

You can't run profitable Google Ads if your pipes are leaking

The campaign looks good but the ads aren't profitable

Topics you'll find on this site