One marketing metric you might not be tracking

Published November 2026. Last updated November 2026.

Where should you spend your marketing budget?

Should you throw more at Google Ads? Would Facebook be profitable? What about Google Local Services Ads, direct mail or other marketing activities?

Get this wrong and you either waste money on a channel that does nothing for the business, or you cut one that was driving profit.

Ideally, you'd base your decisions on a report that said something like:

  • We spent $15,000 on Google Ads last month and made $45,000 in gross profit.
  • We spent $5,000 on Facebook Ads last month and made $3,500 in gross profit.
  • And so on, one line for every channel. All new customers nicely accounted for.

But marketing attribution is rarely this simple.

I've spent years helping businesses figure out which marketing drives sales. But in the last few months I bumped into an idea that changed my thinking:

When it comes to allocating marketing budget, tracking what you don't know might be as important as tracking what you do know.

This came after working with two very experienced agency owners who manage ads on various platforms (Google, Facebook etc).

As you'd expect, they report where their clients' customers come from. "We spent $15,000 on Google Ads last month and made $45,000 in gross profit."

But, they also report on what percentage of new customers don't have a known source. (Take the number of first-time customers with no recorded source and divide it by the total number of first-time customers.)

It's a pretty simple metric but it's surprisingly useful.

1. It tells you if your attribution is improving

If you're investing time and money in improving your attribution, you need some way to measure progress.

If you're introducing call tracking, improving your form tracking or training staff to record lead sources, you should see the percentage of unknown sources fall.

That gives you a way to see whether your efforts are actually making a difference.

2. It can warn you when something goes wrong

Suppose you've managed to get your unknown-source rate down to 20%. Then, over the next couple of months, it starts climbing.

That might suggest a problem with your tracking system. Or maybe the sales team has got sloppy in updating the CRM.

The metric can't tell you what went wrong, but it could warn you that something might be wrong.

3. It tells you how much confidence to place in your attribution reports

If 70% of your new customers have no known source, how confident should you be about the conclusions you're drawing from the other 30%?

For example, say your report shows that your Facebook ads are more profitable than Google Ads. You might be tempted to spend less on Google and more on Facebook.

But it's a bit more nuanced than that. Missing attribution isn't always distributed evenly across your marketing channels.

For example:

  • Facebook leads might come through forms that automatically capture the source and pass it to your CRM.
  • Google Ads leads might arrive by phone, where someone in the office asks how the caller found the business and records the answer.

The first gives you reasonably strong evidence of where the lead came from. The second depends on the customer's memory and the salesperson's interpretation.

Someone who says they found you on Google might have clicked a paid search ad, an organic result, a Local Services Ad or your Google Business Profile.

Both leads have a source recorded in the CRM, but the information isn't equally reliable.

And if one channel is tracked more reliably than another, your reports could make it look more profitable than it really is.

Unknown is better than confidently wrong

I built a system to connect marketing sources to vehicle sales and profit for a group of car dealers.

They advertised through a mixture of online and offline channels. We got reasonably good at tracking the online channels. Tracking customers from offline marketing was more difficult.

One of our biggest frustrations was when a sales person didn't know where a customer came from and they recorded the source as "Walk In".

It drove the boss mad. And for good reason.

Walking into a dealership doesn't explain how someone discovered it:

  • They might have seen the cars at a mall display.
  • Attended a sponsored event.
  • Been referred by a friend.

Or they might have found the business online and then visited in person.

I think being honest when we don't know is more useful than assigning the wrong source.

If you CRM doesn't allow recording that the lead source is unknown you risk being confidently wrong.

How much attribution is enough?

Now I'm not saying that you should move mountains to get the number of unknowns down to zero. That's usually neither possible nor worth the effort.

You need enough reliable information to make sensible decisions about where to spend your marketing budget.

And you need to know what you don't know.

If my thinking resonates with you I'd like to give you a free copy of my book Profitable Google Ads.

Most Google Ads Problems Aren't Google Ads Problems
Pete holding his book
If my writing resonates with you, I'd like to give you a copy of my book, Profitable Google Ads.
Complete the form below to download your free copy. I'll also send you future articles about Google Ads, lead generation, and practical ways to generate more profitable customers from your marketing.

Related articles

Offline conversion tracking with Contact Form 7

Contact Form 7 is one of the most popular form plugins for WordPress. But, if you're running Google Ads, there is a problem. Contact Form 7 can tell you that somebody submitted a form. It can't tell Google Ads if that person became a customer.

Topics you'll find on this site

Agency insights

Thoughts and lessons on client selection, burnout, pricing, and modernising legacy accounts, from someone who's run a Google Ads for years.

Conversion tracking

Understand what happens after someone clicks your advert. Subjects include offline conversions, CRM integration, attribution, auditability and marketing instrumentation.

Essays and thinking

Articles about marketing, engineering, AI and problem solving that don't fit neatly into the other topics. These are some of the ideas and experiences that have shaped how I think.

Google Ads for lead generation

Learn how to use Google Ads to generate profitable leads. Subjects include campaign strategy, bidding, targeting, optimisation and the challenges of running lead generation campaigns.

Landing pages

Things I've learned about high-converting landing pages. Subjects include copywriting, page structure, forms, trust, conversion rate optimisation and user experience.

Sales Process

What happens after a lead has been generated determines if Google Ads is profitable. Subjects include first contact, follow-up, quoting, lead nurturing and turning more enquiries into customers.

© 2026 Pete Bowen

Got a Google Ads question?

Join my free daily Google Ads clinic for business owners. Bring your questions and get practical advice.

Find out more →