The bigger problem hiding behind a Google Ads tracking issue
Fixing the technical details won't help if your website makes it difficult for your best customers to buy.
Published November 2026. Last updated November 2026.
I recently ran a Google Ads pilot campaign for an auto body repair business.
We got two leads the day we launched. Over the next two weeks we got a total of 29 leads at an average cost of $132 per lead.
Sadly we'll never know if Google Ads could have been profitable. Google stopped the ads because the client couldn't complete Google's verification process.
But I thought it might be useful to show you how I set up the campaign, the decisions I made along the way and what we learned.
When a business asks me for help with Google Ads, neither of us knows for certain if Google Ads will be profitable.
I've been doing this for long enough that I've got a good feel for if Google Ads is going to work, but until we actually run some ads we can't be sure. That's why I insist on a pilot campaign to start with.
A pilot is a 2-3 month campaign with a limited budget. It's there to answer questions like:
Let me tell you about how I set up this pilot.
I scoured the business's reviews on Google and Facebook before writing the ads and landing pages. I wanted to find out what their customers valued.
One thing kept coming up: customers were pleased, and sometimes surprised, at how quickly the repairs were done.
It makes sense. Not having your car is a real inconvenience.
So I used "Quick Turnaround" in the ad headlines and something similar on the landing pages.
I also asked the client what questions prospective customers ask them. One of the most common was if the business works with the prospect's insurance company.
Again that makes sense because a lot of car repairs are covered by insurance.
So instead of waiting for someone to contact the business and ask, I preempted the question in the ad copy and again on the landing pages.
These are small details, but they're intended to make it more likely that a click will become a lead.
When someone searches Google, they're trying to solve a problem. The ad needs to show that the business understands that problem and can help. When they click, the landing page needs to confirm the message.
I've written more about the four beliefs I think every landing page needs to establish.
I'll skip most of the geeky details. But I'll tell you about five things I did to give the pilot campaign a reasonable chance of producing useful results.
Google's automated bidding can sometimes make stupid bids for individual clicks - think $300 for a click when the average was $20.
For a pilot campaign with a tight budget that'd blow the whole day's money on one click.
You can stop this happening using a portfolio bidding strategy. More on that in Why did Google charge me $300 for a $20 click.
Google wants you to write lots of ad copy so they can mix and match what you've written to come up with ads they think are good.
I deliberately don't allow that in a pilot campaign.
I prefer to keep tight control over what the ads say even though Google warns about poor ad strength. That gives me more control over the messages people see and makes the results easier to interpret.
I applied my five standard negative keyword lists to the campaign.
These help stop our ads showing to people that aren't likely to be good leads.
I set up tracking for both phone calls and contact forms. The tracking system deduplicates leads so if someone fills in the form and then calls Google only counts one lead.
I also set up conversion tracking for qualified leads and leads that became sales. The client would give me this information using the Litiro dashboard. More on this here.
Finally, I scheduled the advertisements to run only during weekday office hours.
There was nobody available to respond outside this time and I didn't want to spend our limited budget generating leads that'd go cold.
I hate launching new campaigns. A few hours without a lead and I'm convinced I'm a failure. That I'm doomed to spend the rest of my life working in a salt mine. (Feel sorry for my wife. She has to put up with my panic.)
Luckily the first two leads arrived on launch day.
Here are the overall results:
| Metric | Result |
|---|---|
| Impressions | 10,387 |
| Clicks | 212 |
| Advertising spend | $3,818 |
| Individual leads | 29 |
| Cost per enquiry | $132 |
| Click-to-enquiry conversion rate | 14% |
And here are the daily results.
| Day | Cost | Conversions |
|---|---|---|
| Day 1 | $133 | 2 |
| Day 2 | $383 | 3 |
| Day 3 | $325 | 0 |
| Day 4 | $231 | 3 |
| Day 5 | $436 | 1 |
| Day 6 | $356 | 5 |
| Day 7 | $311 | 2 |
| Day 8 | $171 | 2 |
| Day 9 | $359 | 4 |
| Day 10 | $537 | 2 |
| Day 11 | $578 | 5 |
| Total | $3,818 | 29 |
Total spend uses the Google Ads figure; individual daily costs are rounded.
The first leads arrived on launch day, but there were also days when we got no leads, even though we'd paid for clicks.
It's easy to get nervous when you see money going out without leads coming in. But a day without leads doesn't necessarily mean something has gone wrong. The small numbers can make normal variations look terrible. Although it's nerve-wracking to wait, you get a more accurate picture when you look at performance over a few weeks.
About 14% of people who clicked an ad made an enquiry. That made me happy. It's an early sign that the messages in the ad copy and landing page were resonating with prospective customers.
I also went through the actual search terms our ads showed for every day and added any irrelevant searches I found.
Google doesn't show us every search term anymore, so this isn't as effective as it used to be. But I still think it's worth doing, particularly during the first few weeks.
Initially, I'd included ads for auto glass replacement because I didn't know if we'd get enough leads without it. But during the pilot, the client told me it wasn't very profitable for them.
Once the leads started flowing I realised that there were enough for other services and paused these ads.
I should probably have asked which services were most profitable before launching. It's a useful reminder that what matters isn't just how many leads Google Ads generates, but what those leads are worth to the business.
This is also part of what a pilot is for. You start with the information you have, see what happens and learn more about the business as you go.
From what I could see the leads looked like a good fit and the cost per lead was good compared with the value of a typical job.
We'd agreed before launching that the client would give me feedback on the leads. Unfortunately, operational difficulties stopped them from doing this.
That means I can't tell you if the advertising was profitable.
If we had carried on with the campaign we'd have solved the feedback issues.
Unfortunately, there was a much more significant problem.
Sometimes Google imposes an exhaustive business verification process after the ads start. This has to be handled by the advertiser. I tried to help but in the end they weren't able to complete the verification and Google stopped the ads.
It was disappointing.
Partly.
We established that Google Ads could generate what appeared to be relevant enquiries at a reasonable cost. We also discovered that there was enough demand for the business's more profitable services.
What we couldn't establish was whether those enquiries would become profitable customers.
That's an important distinction, and it's why I don't judge Google Ads campaigns on cost per lead alone.
It's also why I prefer starting with a pilot. You can do all the research in the world, but eventually you have to spend some money to find out what actually happens.
If you're considering Google Ads for your own business, here's how my pilot campaigns work.
Fixing the technical details won't help if your website makes it difficult for your best customers to buy.
One Google Ads problem. Seven different recommendations. How do you know which advice to trust?
Two Google Ads campaigns deliver the same revenue. But one creates five times as much work for the sales team.
What I'd do when Google Ads leads disappear and nobody can explain why.
How a successful Google Ads campaign can leave your business short of cash.
Two tricky targeting problems, a possible campaign strategy, and one important question: can we generate profitable leads?
Thoughts and lessons on client selection, burnout, pricing, and modernising legacy accounts, from someone who's run a Google Ads for years.
Understand what happens after someone clicks your advert. Subjects include offline conversions, CRM integration, attribution, auditability and marketing instrumentation.
Articles about marketing, engineering, AI and problem solving that don't fit neatly into the other topics. These are some of the ideas and experiences that have shaped how I think.
How to choose the right Google Ads agency, set them up to succeed, judge their work fairly, and build a relationship that delivers better business results.
Learn how to use Google Ads to generate profitable leads. Subjects include campaign strategy, bidding, targeting, optimisation and the challenges of running lead generation campaigns.
Understand why some leads become customers while others don't. Subjects include diagnosing poor leads, qualification, filtering junk leads and improving the feedback you send to Google Ads.
Things I've learned about high-converting landing pages. Subjects include copywriting, page structure, forms, trust, conversion rate optimisation and user experience.
What happens after a lead has been generated determines if Google Ads is profitable. Subjects include first contact, follow-up, quoting, lead nurturing and turning more enquiries into customers.
Join my free daily Google Ads clinic for business owners. Bring your questions and get practical advice.
Find out more →